Tortoise: Beacons Of Ancestorship

Tagged with:
Tortoise 

Written By:

David Morris

07th June 2009
At 23:58 GMT

8 comment(s)

Support new music: choose from our favourite new albums this month.

I’ve never seen Alien, I’ve never tasted Sake and I’ve never listened to Tortoise. Over the last couple of weeks I have been putting that to rights, doing all three at once every morning at the crow of the cock. My encounters with the Sarky Alien Tortoise are beginning to bear fruit, but how much this fruit resembles the chosen gut-rot of you Tortoise fans out there is not something I can comment on. Is it a Nectarine? Is it a sweet banana rising from the ashes of the starchy plantain? Or is the potato reverting to its poisonous ancestry? Tuba? No there’s no tuba’s here, but there is a good slab of skronkiness.  

Initially our little tête a tête’s were soured by an imbalance. Tortoise are Kings! How can I possibly approach them with such meagre apparatus. Kings of what I didn’t know, except that their kingdom shared borders with The Jazz Banana Republic, and that an exiled group of upstarts are responsible for a lot of piss-poor instrumental rock. What if I don’t like it? The first rule of guerrilla warfare is to know the country, to develop a firm base in the jungle and earn the respect and affiliation of the peasant folk. I didn’t have chance! Fortunately for me there is no overweight monarch slumped astride the Beacons of Ancestorship, so instead I took a tourist bus through this new city. Sort of like judging Lhasa by spending a few weeks in the new Chinese suburbs. No, it’s not like that at all. But there is a kinky industrial vibration kicking around these parts… 

An admission: The one-off inclusion of Ennio Morrico-Leone arabesque percussion and reverbed guitar in the form of ‘The Fall of Seven Diamonds Plus One’ renders me rather unfit to judge the album. Because I love Spaghetti Western music in a way I can only explain by informing you that a few nights ago I told my friends that I wanted a track from the Dollars trilogy played at my funeral. The one that has the really epic “HOO- HUH!” in it. I’m like the kid in the Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe, and this is my Turkish Delight. Unfortunately this doesn’t re-occur on the almost coincidentally titled ‘Prepare Your Coffin’ which is instead the robo-rockiest album closer. 

What this record sounds like is a group of dudes messing around with exceptional toys via exceptional rhythm and a highly individual sense of taste and restraint. Luckily it’s no Nouveau Cuisine; there are a good few chunks of meat, enough to make me feel that I haven’t been ripped off. ‘Monument Six One Thousand’ is very instrumental Radiohead circa right this minute plus Amnesiac (yes yes yes, maybe they’re very Tortoise sometimes, I told you already). Is that drum loop slowing down, or am I speeding up?  

They’re really loving that chunky gravel guitar sound. ‘Charteroak Foundation’ (no, not the Connecticut tax exempt corporation, let me finish) sounds like an alien take on some of the loungey Todd Rundgreny music my housemate has been listening to in between sessions with a ‘13 methods for Closing a Sale’ LP, his latest sick puppy brought home from the carboot. Albeit remixed by someone cool. 

‘High Class Slim Came Floatin’ In’ is a bit of a… what do our American brethren say? A Curveball. It starts out all trip-hop beats, fatty batty bass, and lighter than air synth swirl flutters which mutate into earthy moos and grainy drones. It makes me feel rather expectant of a bit of bombastic explosioneering, but then drops out into some angular jerkalong riffing and offbeat buzz bleats. Like a bomber that doesn’t drop the payload, distracted by pretty colours in the sky, flying over it’s target beyond the war to Never Never Land. It’s light and playful, a mood which dominates the album.  

‘Gigantes’ is one of the “chunk of meat” tracks (alongside ‘Yinxianghechengqi’), hammer dulcimer ringing clear over squelching synthesizers and tight as ever layers of interlocking percussion. They seem to be the kind of band who don’t feel the need to have everybody doing something all of the time, like when you see Radiohead’s Ed O’Brien playing the tambourine sparsely at live shows, and really enjoying himself. Good on you Ed, cause that’s all it needs sometimes, nice tambourine playing. The distant eerie groans of the filtered brass sounds work very well with the glassy synth strings, texturally masterful like most of the record. Why don’t I love it? It’s just that for me this kind of robot gets funky noodling isn’t compatible with my software, haw-haw-haw… it does get a bit bland here and there. 

Semi important paragraph concepts that didn’t make the grade (the sun is shining): I don’t like Pink Floyd so how can you trust me / Damn them for not making an albums worth of ‘The Fall of Seven Diamonds Plus One’ / Does this sound better in the Big City? / Would it be good to shoot to? Discussions with myself re: lame rip-offs of Hunter Thompson prose / I bet it sounds great live.

Rating:  6 / 10

Bookmark this page:

delicious icon Stumble Upon icon Digg icon

User Comments

5

Comment By:

Patrick Alexander

commented 10 months ago

Just a bunch of self-satisfied intellectual masturbation and aimlessly cerebral noodling. Not the album; this review.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

5

Comment By:

Aidan W.

commented 10 months ago

Oooh, burn.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

3

Comment By:

David Morris

commented 10 months ago

Well as this music didn't physically, spiritually or emotionally engage me, there's nothing much left but the cerebral for me to write about. It was the way I as a listener responded to it, which is the only way I know how. But I don't feel like I attacked it, or tried to undermine it to serve my own purposes. I've certainly got nothing against it. I tried to get across that by not being a Tortoise fan, and not knowing their back catalogue, makes it a different kind of appraisal.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

-2

Comment By:

Gavin

commented 10 months ago

I love Tortoise, I have practically everything they've ever recorded, yet this album was missing something. Whether they've peaked or not - time will only tell.

But it feels like they've hit the limiter. They've lost the magnetism they once had.

Interestingly David, have you heard the Bonnie Prince Billy collab record?

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

-5

Comment By:

David Morris

commented 10 months ago

Yeah I have, though I never bought a copy. I wasn't that taken by it, though I thought it was good move outside of their usual work, presumably for both. It had some good quirks and was certainly unique.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

5

Comment By:

helas

commented 10 months ago

The Bonnie Prince Billy collab record is a grower, IMO. It didn't grab me at first but now I think it's fun and totally worthwhile. Being a longtime Tortoise fan, my hopes for BoA are high - but I guess as long as it's a step above their last, It's All Around You, I'll be placated enough and will continue to pay close attention. Also, they're GREAT live, and that oughtta hold me over for another three to five years, which is likely how long it'll take for the next record.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

2

Comment By:

David Morris

commented 10 months ago

You've prompted me to go have a listen there Helas!

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

7

Comment By:

birch

commented 10 months ago

When I first got my hands on an advance copy I drooled with anticipation - as Tortoise is my favorite band, period.

The sound on the album is so inspired in parts, and so mind-numbingly uninspired in others. Gigantes is by far the highlight for me. And "High Class" is another a close second (followed by Charteroak Foundation.) But, beyond that, it's a dissapointment. The album as a whole does comes across boldly and it does sound as if they're trying to change their sound (most noticeably, there's a complete absence of the vibraphone...which had such a substantial role on every previous album of theirs.) But, there are just too many boring songs here.

I can't wait for the follow-up 5-inchers to be released shortly after. Hopefully the band kept some gems for those, because there surely aren't many on the new album.

Rate This Comment:

I Agree Comment Sucks

Have your say

Want to save time entering your info and save your comments?